Did Kim Min-jae leave because Jonathan has arrived? The choices of Munich and the variable of Musiala’s injury.

PSG Match Review: 0-2 Despite Numerical Advantage, Inefficiency Leads to Elimination

Bayern advanced to the quarterfinals after defeating Flamengo following a group stage of 2 wins and 1 loss. The first half against a peak-performing PSG was balanced, but the lack of accuracy in the finishing stages proved to be a setback.

After conceding the first goal in the 68th minute, Bayern gained a numerical advantage due to consecutive red cards for the opposing defenders, yet they failed to make an impact in penetration, crosses, or second balls. Instead, a counterattack in stoppage time led to Hakimi’s breakthrough and Dembélé’s decisive strike, solidifying the score at 0-2.

Musiala’s Ankle Injury: Tactical and Psychological Blow

Musiala was substituted due to an ankle injury sustained from a collision in the penalty area. While some speculate it may not lead to a long-term absence, forecasts suggest recovery could take several months. The loss of a player known for his quick turns, forward dribbling, and link-up play in half-spaces is likely to weaken Kompany’s attacking build-up options (internal inverts/line breaking).

Musiala’s absence could lead to a simultaneous weakening of ‘ball carrying’ and ‘creating numerical superiority’ abilities. Ultimately, the perceived quality of finishing in the attacking front may decline further.

Jonatan Tah’s Arrival and Kim Min-jae’s Status: Replacement or Reinforcement?

The arrival of Jonatan Tah, a key defender from Bayer Leverkusen, has indeed amplified rumors regarding Kim Min-jae’s transfer. However, in Kompany’s system, which employs a high line tactic, the core competencies of the defensive line are ‘transition response speed’ and ‘covering behind the line.’

• Comparison of strengths: Tah excels in build-up stability and managing distances between players, while Kim Min-jae stands out in recovery speed, coverage range, and recovery tackles in one-on-one situations.
• Tactical suitability: When maintaining a high line, Kim Min-jae has a comparative advantage in filling spaces behind the line through acceleration and angle judgment.
• Squad composition: Considering the need to balance cup competitions, league, and European stages, a rotation of 3-4 center-backs is essential. It is premature to conclude that Tah’s signing is simply a ‘replacement.’

Need for Rebuilding Offensive Resources: Why is Scoring Stagnant?

The variance in the condition of wide players, decreased accuracy in crosses, and monotony in the types of penalty box occupancy have highlighted deficiencies. The failure to realize scoring expectations in big matches is also related to a lack of set-piece diversity.

• Expanding options in the final third relative to ball possession (half-space penetration, rotation patterns)
• Updating set-piece tactics (mixing near/far patterns, strengthening second-line penetration scenarios)
• Reinforcing line-breaker types (speedy wingers/second striker profiles)

Kim Min-jae’s Stay vs Transfer: Realistic Scenarios

• Stay logic: Possesses core competencies for high line tactics (recovery speed, coverage range). With Musiala’s absence, attacking reinforcement is a priority, making defensive departures a risk.
• Transfer logic: Excessive criticism noise from some fans and media, potential fluctuations in playing time, and the allure of challenging in the Premier League.

Considering the current squad structure and tactical demands, staying is likely the most reasonable choice for both the team and the player in the short term. However, variables at the end of the summer transfer market (failure to reinforce attack/balancing expenditures) should be monitored.

Fan Perspective Points: Differences Observed in the PSG Match

• Managing numerical superiority: Need to transition from repetitive fixed crosses to occupying half-spaces and cutback pattern changes
• Transition speed: Accelerating tempo from second ball recovery to penetration
• Distance between lines: Adjusting the protection width of the second line when maintaining a high line (blocking counterattacks)